This is a question that comes up mainly when someone is considering having a house built. It doesn’t come up too much with an existing building because the deed is done by then and although you can scrap what you’ve got completely and give it a complete new look, reroofing costs both time and money. It’s best to get it right the first time, then. So, which is better, a flat roof or a pitched roof?

The answer depends on your needs and aesthetic preferences. Each option has its strengths and drawbacks, but they also offer distinctly different looks. For homeowners considering roofing in Milwaukee , the choice might come down to what complements your home’s design and fits within your neighborhood. And even if you’re not concerned about blending in with the neighborhood, there is the question of what your house looks like to you.

Many of the great roofs of the world are pitched. Even in a regular area of Wisconsin, you may find all the churches and the smaller civic buildings have pitched roofs. There is something about those steep angles and intersecting planes that adds elegance. Flat roofs tend to be on functional buildings. But why is that?

Let’s look at some of the general claims to fame.

Advantages and Disadvantages of a Pitched Roof

Let’s talk aesthetics first. A very steep pitched roof with planes to the north, south, east, and west is indefinably stylish with a very distinct look. The shingles, too, can be a source of style.

From a practical point of view, you get durability. A pitched roof will generally last a lot longer, and for several reasons. The steep slopes shed water and dislodge snow faster, and the last thing you want is water and ice, plus all the plant debris the wind blows your way, hanging around up there.

On the other hand, a pitched roof can be more delicate, so you might be replacing shingles after a storm. But there again, what’s a shingle or two?

Then there are all the joins, the angles that have to be sealed. Sometimes a roofer gets twitchy looking at one of those fancy oriental roofs which is all apparently unnecessary extra little pitched pieces, turrety-looking bits, and decorations. Imagine being in charge of maintenance for that. It must be one leak after another. But a straightforward American pitched roof going side to side, front to back, or even both: a bit of judicious flashing work and you’re covered.

What is the Major Disadvantage of a Flat Roof?

Standing water: simple as that. But even then, a good flat roof may be perfectly flat in that it’s one smooth plane, but it is not horizontal. The water has to be allowed to run off, so there has to be a slight angle one way or another. You decide which end you want the water to exit via, put a gutter along it and there you go. So, the answer to the question of which is better, a flat or a sloped roof, is that they’re all sloped, but a flat one not nearly so much. Hardly at all, in fact, but enough.

As for cost, a simple flat roof is easier to construct, but modern materials – which do a great job, by the way – can be expensive. If cost is a major consideration, you need to get ballpark figures from your roofer.

Another disadvantage of a flat roof is the tendency to crack. Because it tends to be a thick layer of something (used to be asphalt but now probably something more sophisticated such as fiberglass), cracking can occur, and you should keep an eye on a flat roof to check if it needs help. Don’t wait until you see water damage inside - staining is damage and when you see it, it’s too late. That’s another bit of renovation or at least redecoration for you to do.

If you're still unsure, consulting local professionals like Racine roofers or roofers in Franklin , if you live in the area, can provide you with insights based on their experience with Wisconsin’s weather and architectural styles.

What is the Most Popular Roof Type in Wisconsin?

A statistician somewhere may have the statewide answer, but which do you see more of in your area? And anyway, do you buy a certain kind of car just because everyone else has one? If you want a stylish, elegant look, maybe you should go for a pitched roof. If you want a tougher but less pretty number, although ironically it may last only 15 years or so, go for a flat one.

The important thing is to talk to a trusted roofing company in your local area like Four Leaf Roofing & Windows , and discuss all the different options. Find out what they are accustomed to and if possible, get a personal recommendation from someone you know. If you’re going for a flat roof but want an extra tough one with a thick concrete base on it, talk to them about it. May it be pitched or flat roof, learn everything you can about roofing quotes also so there are no surprises.

Whichever option you go for, you deserve to get a good job done. There is no right and wrong in this: it’s your building and your decision, just be aware of the possibilities and go with the right people.