Our home is usually, far and away, the biggest purchase of our lives. We invest a lot of time looking for just the right place to call home, checking for the perfect neighborhood, evaluating walkability, and seeing what fun restaurants and gathering places might be nearby. Once we sign for the house and get the keys, we quickly come to understand that as homeowners we are now responsible for all maintenance and major repairs. One of the biggest upgrades that we may have to decide on is the best roofing materials for a new roof.

The Primary Options

While often the decision comes down to asphalt shingles vs metal, roofing material options also include tile. As you evaluate each of these possible options, it's important to take into consideration their pros and cons.

Factors such as aesthetics, durability, and suitability for your specific climate zone will also come into play. A new roof is a significant investment you will live with for quite a while, so it's well worth the time sorting through the roofing materials comparison. For professional guidance, Four Leaf Roofing & Windows can help you select the perfect material for your home.

Asphalt Shingles: Pros and Cons

Asphalt shingles are a popular option, as they are one of the most affordable materials you can choose for your new roof. In addition, they are relatively easy to install, which saves money on labor. They are offered in a variety of styles and colors, so the homeowner can decide on their specific roof color and look. If the shingles are ever damaged, they can be individually replaced.

If you're looking for trusted roofing companies in Milwaukee , choosing a contractor experienced in asphalt shingle installations is essential for long-lasting results.

Asphalt Shingles: Additional Information

Shingles are typically made from either fiberglass or an organic paper mat that is enclosed in asphalt and then coated with granules of mineral.

If you live in a humid climate, you may need to choose shingles that are algae-resistant in order to prevent staining. Additionally, professional roofing services in Oak Creek can assist with asphalt roof maintenance and repairs.

Metal Roofing: Pros and Cons

When comparing asphalt vs metal roofing durability, metal is the clear winner. Metal roofs can last for forty to seventy years. Metal is known to be very resistant and durable in the face of extreme weather such as heavy snow, high winds, or hail. It's also energy efficient, reflecting the heat of the sun and thus reducing cooling expenses in hotter climates. Ongoing maintenance costs are very low, and most metal roofs are recyclable too.

One of the cons of metal roofing is that it can be more expensive than relatively affordable asphalt shingles. Some customers also find metal to be noisy when there is hail or heavy rainstorms, although insulation can reduce the noise levels. If you’re considering metal roofing, consulting with residential siding experts in Milwaukee can help you integrate roofing and siding for a cohesive look.

Metal Roofing: Additional Information

Metal roofs will often be made from aluminum or steel. They may also be crafted from titanium, zinc, or copper, which has been known to last for up to one hundred years.

They may be available as metal panels that are corrugated, or in standing seam forms. You may typically find metal on ranch, bungalow, cottage, or contemporary roofs.

Tile Roofing: Pros and Cons

Tile roofs are also very durable, often lasting for fifty to one hundred years. They are ideal for Spanish-style or Mediterranean homes and offer a classic and unique appearance. When they are correctly installed, there is very little maintenance required. Tile is also very resistant to damage from fire, insects, or rot.

One of the cons of tile is that it is extremely heavy, so it may require you to install additional support for your structure and increase initial installation costs. Individual tiles might crack if hit by hail or falling branches. If you’re in Muskego, trusted roofing services in Muskego can help evaluate the structural requirements for tile roofing.

Tile Roofing: Additional Information

Tiles are generally made of concrete or clay and can be a bit brittle if you don't handle them with a lot of care.

Clay tiles range in cost from $800 to $1000 cost/square, while you can expect to pay $300 to $500 per square for concrete tiles. To determine if repairs or a replacement are the best solution, check out our guide on roof repair vs. replacement: making the right choice.

If you are looking to invest in a new roof for your home, you'll have to choose between asphalt shingles, metal, and tile roofing. Your local roofer can guide you through the choices and can help you come to a decision that is just right for your home.