(160+ Ratings & Reviews)

4.9

*Up to 0% Financing for up to 21 Months

What Is a CertainTeed ShingleMaster PRO Warranty? 3-Star vs 4-Star SureStart PLUS

Guide to the CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty, comparing 3-Star and 4-Star protection for residential roofs

New Berlin, WI, sits at the center of Waukesha County, where roofs absorb 47 inches of annual snowfall and 160 freeze-thaw cycles per year.

If you’re investing $10,000 to $22,000 in a roof replacement, the warranty protecting that system is as critical as the shingles themselves.

The CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty is where many homeowners unknowingly leave coverage on the table.

Your contractor’s certification level, not your shingle choice, determines how many years of full labor and material protection you receive.

In New Berlin, that gap can mean the difference between 10 years and 25 years of 100% coverage.

How the CertainTeed SureStart PLUS Warranty Actually Works

The CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty is a non-prorated, full-replacement warranty that reimburses 100% of both labor and material costs for qualifying defects during the active coverage window. It is not the standard shingle product warranty you receive automatically at purchase.

Standard warranties only protect the shingle material. The CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty adds full labor coverage, the portion that typically costs more than materials in a warranty repair, which makes it the real protection New Berlin homeowners need to ask for.

Infographic comparing 3-Star and 4-Star CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty coverage for New Berlin roofs

Breaking Down the Star Levels: What Each Tier Covers

CertainTeed uses a 1 to 4-star rating system tied directly to your installer’s certification. The higher the tier, the longer and more complete your SureStart PLUS protection.

3-Star SureStart PLUS: Entry-Level Enhanced Coverage

The 3-Star CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty is issued by Select ShingleMaster-certified contractors.

It includes a 50-year non-prorated product warranty paired with 10 years of full labor and material coverage under SureStart PLUS.

When evaluating the Certainteed 3-star vs. 4-star warranty decision, the 10-year labor coverage window seems sufficient until you consider that a properly installed asphalt shingle roof in Wisconsin lasts 20 to 30 years. The coverage ends long before the roof does.

4-Star SureStart PLUS: Maximum Protection for New Berlin Roofs

The 4-Star CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty is available exclusively through ShingleMaster PRO certified contractors.

Four Leaf Roofing & Windows holds this credential, earned through advanced CertainTeed installer training, an on-staff Shingle Quality Specialist requirement, and verified installation volume standards.

A 4-Star installation includes:

  • Lifetime non-prorated product warranty on qualifying CertainTeed shingle lines.
  • 25 years of full labor and material coverage under SureStart PLUS.
  • Wind coverage up to 130 mph on Landmark PRO and Landmark IR lines.
  • StreakFighter® algae resistance is warranted up to 15 years.

For homes along New Berlin’s Calhoun Road or the Moorland Road corridor areas that regularly absorb hail from southeastern Wisconsin storm systems, 25 years of full coverage is a measurable financial safety net.

Four Leaf Roofing & Windows is New Berlin’s ShingleMaster PRO-certified installer. A free 45–60 minute inspection determines your roof’s condition and the exact warranty tier you’ll receive, with no obligation required. Get your free estimate today!

Your Installer’s Certification Locks In Your Coverage Tier

The CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty tier is set at installation and cannot be upgraded after the fact.

A homeowner can select Landmark PRO shingles and still receive only 2-Star coverage if their contractor doesn’t hold the right certification.

Warranty Tier

Contractor Certification

SureStart PLUS Labor Coverage

Product Warranty

2-Star

Standard certified installer

2 years

25-year prorated

3-Star

Select ShingleMaster

10 years

50-year non-prorated

4-Star

ShingleMaster PRO

25 years

Lifetime non-prorated

This is precisely why selecting a CertainTeed ShingleMaster PRO contractor in New Berlin carries more weight than the shingle brand you choose.

The CertainTeed integrity roof system extends this principle further when a contractor installs matching CertainTeed components, including starter strips, underlayment, hip and ridge shingles, and ventilation.

The full assembly qualifies for unified system protection. The Certainteed Integrity Roof System warranty covers failures caused by component interaction, not just isolated material defects.

If you’re researching a roof replacement in New Berlin, ask every contractor which warranty star level they can issue and get it in writing before the contract is signed.

See what 4-Star Warranty Coverage looks like on a New Berlin roof! Every project Four Leaf completes qualifies for maximum SureStart PLUS coverage, no hidden tier downgrades, and no surprises after installation. Explore Residential Roofing in New Berlin today!

Don’t Miss the 60-Day Registration Window

CertainTeed warranty registration must be completed within 60 days of your roof’s installation date.

Homeowners who miss this window lose all SureStart PLUS labor coverage, dropping to standard product-only protection with no labor reimbursement.

Four Leaf Roofing & Windows handles registration for every project we complete across New Berlin and southeastern Wisconsin.

If a different contractor installed your roof, verify your registration status immediately. You can review the official guidelines for CertainTeed’s worry-free warranties to see exactly what is required.

Wisconsin roof warranty registration deadlines carry no grace period. An unregistered warranty provides no SureStart PLUS coverage at all. 

The CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty is also transferable to a new homeowner within 60 days of a property sale.

In New Berlin’s active real estate market, a documented lifetime warranty with 25 years of labor coverage remaining is a genuine competitive advantage at closing.

Key Takeaways

Your Warranty Should Outlast Wisconsin Winters | Make Sure It Does

New Berlin roofs take on 47 inches of snow, near-annual hail events, and 160 freeze-thaw cycles every year. A premium shingle without the right warranty backing is only part of the investment.

The 4-Star CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty with a lifetime shingle warranty and 25 full years of labor and material coverage is the complete version.

Four Leaf Roofing & Windows earned ShingleMaster PRO certification, so every New Berlin homeowner we serve qualifies for maximum warranty coverage.

We pull permits, register your warranty within the required window, document every detail, and stay accountable long after installation day.

Don’t settle for 10 years of coverage when 25 years is available at the same installation cost.

Four Leaf Roofing & Windows | New Berlin, WI | ShingleMaster PRO Certified | 4.9 Stars · 160+ Google Reviews

Find Us on Google Maps | Click Here to Get Started!

Protect your home with a CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty. Banner for stress-free 4-Star roof coverage

Frequently Asked Questions About the CertainTeed SureStart PLUS Warranty

What is a CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty?

The CertainTeed SureStart PLUS warranty is a non-prorated plan that reimburses 100% of both labor and material costs for qualifying defects during the active coverage period.

It is available only through certified contractors, Select ShingleMaster for 3-Star or ShingleMaster PRO for 4-Star, and is not included in standard shingle purchases.

A 3-Star SureStart PLUS warranty covers 100% of labor and materials for 10 years, paired with a 50-year non-prorated product warranty, issued through Select ShingleMaster contractors.

A 4-Star warranty extends full labor and material coverage to 25 years with a lifetime product warranty, available exclusively through ShingleMaster PRO certified contractors.

The CertainTeed Integrity Roof System covers the complete roofing assembly under one unified warranty, including shingles, underlayment, starter strips, hip and ridge components, and ventilation accessories.

All components must be CertainTeed-branded and installed by a certified contractor for system-level warranty coverage to apply.

Complete your CertainTeed warranty registration at CertainTeed.com within 60 days of the installation date.

Missing this deadline eliminates all SureStart PLUS labor coverage and reverts protection to a standard product-only warranty.

Ask your contractor to confirm registration was submitted and request written documentation for your records.

(414) 455-2345